Book Review: The Library After Dark by Ande Pliego

Rating: ★★★★★
Audience: Mystery/Thriller
Length: 368 pages
Author: Ande Pliego
Publisher: Bantam
Release Date: May 5th, 2026
Image & Other Reviews on: Goodreads

BOOK SUMMARY:

A bookseller must escape the infamously haunted library that holds her darkest secrets, but with a murderer in her tour group, escaping alive is not as simple as it seems, in this twisty locked-room thriller from bestselling author of You Are Fatally Invited.

Not all fairytales were meant for children.

Aria Stokes is finally feeling settled—she lives in a tiny New York apartment, works as a bookseller at a local shop, and has even taken a leap of faith in love by indulging her attraction to bookstore regular Jasper. And he seems to already know her so well.

As a Valentine’s Day surprise, Jasper gets the two of them tickets to an exclusive, after-dark tour of the Daedalus Library—the grandiose establishment famed for its immersive genre-based reading rooms and, more notoriously, its rumored hauntings. While Aria normally loves all things ghastly, this place holds more dark secrets than she’d prefer Jasper to know. Like that the last time she was here, she left a body behind.

But when the automatic-door entry malfunctions and Aria, Jasper, and the five other people in their tour group become trapped in the library, they are forced to venture through the storied rooms and hidden passageways of the Daedalus in search of escape . . . and Aria quite literally has nowhere to hide from the shadows of her past. Then the group learns there’s a murderer in their midst.

Now, as she tries to break out of the library’s intricate reading rooms, Aria has to decide who she can trust—and what secrets are best kept buried—if she wants to make it out alive.

COLOR ME SHOCKED.

This was 100% on none of my radars. None. Yet here I am giving it five stars after a friend’s recommendation. I am shocked, but I am happy.

What stood out to me most was that I could NOT figure out who the bad guy was. Very creepy things kept happening in the library that were blindsiding me and I kept going, well who’s doing it???! I liked the dramatic edge of this library and that it had a escape room vibe too.

The audiobook was great with multiple narrators for each of the multiple POV’s making it really easy to keep the story straight. I do admit to having some confusion when the reveals started happening because I was trying to remember who was who (there were a lot of names to keep up with).

I know this doesn’t have a great Goodreads rating but I accept being in the minority on this book. If you’re looking for a thriller with a different energy and genuinely not knowing who you could trust AND who will make it out alive, try this one!!

Overall audience notes

  • Thriller
  • Language: mild
  • Violence: high
  • Content warnings: murder, serial killers

Instagram || Goodreads || The StoryGraph

Leave a Reply