
Rating: ★★★.25
Audience: Contemporary Romance
Length: 368 pages
Author: Deborah M. Hathaway
Publisher: Draft Horse Publishing
Release Date: September 30th, 2026
Image & Other Reviews on: Goodreads
BOOK SUMMARY:
The good news? My five-year crush finally noticed me. The bad news? My dad noticed, too.
I told myself I’d outgrown my crush on cowboy Archer Kade—somewhere between braces, pimply skin, and writing his-name-plus-mine on every page of my diary.
Turns out, I was wrong.
I’m back from college for the fall, and that old crush is back, too. But this time, Archer’s not the young, ex-rodeo star I used to dream about. He’s a man making me laugh, walking me home, and trying to get my attention as much as I used to want his.
The only person who isn’t thrilled with this development?
My dad, the mayor of Autumn Ridge.
He says Archer’s trouble. I say I know he is—but I just can’t help myself. Especially when Archer’s suddenly everywhere. Helping with the fall festival. Running Horseshoe Holler Stables. Looking at me like I’m not that teenager who used to wear too much sparkly eyeshadow to catch his attention.
I left Autumn Ridge to get over him. This autumn, Archer might prove I never really did.

DADDY ISSUES.
I had one big glaring issue with this book and I just could not get past it. For a woman who is TWENTY TWO, she was way too focused on what her Dad thought. It was practically on every page about whether or not he would approve and what we was going to think and so on. I get it to a degree, a lot of us don’t want to disappoint our parents, but at some point you have got to have a conversation and separation.
Mostly I was invested to see who Dad [the mayor] was dating as this has been a theme throughout the series. You do find out the information at 90% or so, so there’s that.
There were some sweet moments with Archer. I did like him a lot. I thought the Texan accent was spoken well by the narrator without feeling comical and that Archer showed growth and learning from past mistakes. The kissing scenes were on point too.
I’ve read MANY of Hathaway’s books and this was an unfortunate miss. I still plan to read her next book though.
Overall audience notes:
- Contemporary Romance
- Language: none
- Romance: kisses
- Violence: low
- Content warnings: loss of loved ones (recounted)

Instagram || Goodreads || The StoryGraph



