Rating: ★★★★
Audience: YA Historical Fantasy
Length: 448 pages
Author: Julie Berry
Publisher: Simon Teen
Release Date: Septemer 16th, 2025
Image & Other Reviews on: Goodreads

BOOK SUMMARY:

From Printz Honor–winning and New York Times bestselling author Julie Berry, a true-crime-nailbiter-turned-mythic-odyssey pitting Jack the Ripper against Medusa. A defiant love song to sisterhood, a survivors’ battle cry, and a romantic literary tour de force laced with humor.

It’s autumn 1888, and Jack the Ripper is on the run. As London police close in, he flees England for New York City seeking new victims. But a primal force of female vengeance has had enough. With serpents for hair and a fearsome gaze, an awakened Medusa is hunting for one Jack.

And other dangers lurk in Manhattan’s Bowery. Salvation Army volunteers Tabitha and Pearl discover that a girl they once helped has been forced to work in a local brothel. Tabitha’s an upstate city girl with a wry humor and a thirst for adventure, while farmgirl Pearl takes everything with stone-cold seriousness. Their brittle partnership is tested as they team up with an aspiring girl reporter and a handsome Irish bartender to mount a rescue effort, only to find their fates entwine with Medusa’s and Jack’s.

Thank you to Simon Teen for the ARC and Simon Audio for the audiobook (gifted).

WELL.

I feel like my thoughts are kind of scattered on this book y’all. The Lovely War is one of my all time favorite historical fantasies and I was ecstatic to get my hands on Julie Berry’s next book, but this one left me wanting on some fronts.

The feminist rage was a heavy theme throughout. And while I often don’t mind it I think it lacked some balance. I do remember some really great sentiments surrounding being a survivor, where does religion fit in, and helping friends through dark places. There was an interesting crossing of multiple topics that did start to make sense as the story went on.

I wish the romance had been a bit more prominent. I don’t mind no romance/low romance stories because when it works, it works. If Looks Could Kill felt like it needed a little more depth to that plot line rather than it feeling wayward. I did enjoy Tabitha’s romance, just gimme mooooore.

The multiple POV’s lent to seeing many different sides of the characters actions, thoughts and various story lines. I loved seeing each of them. The darkness, suffering and revival allowed each character to land where they should be. I liked the ending and appreciated the closure it gave to the main characters. The Medusa x Jack the Ripper combination was very unique and the clear research and dedication that went into crafting this novel was amazing as always from Julie Berry.

Overall audience notes:

• YA Historical Fantasy
• Language: low
• Romance: flirting (maybe a kiss?)
• Violence: high
• Content warnings: religious bigotry, racism, death, sexual assault and r*pe, drug and alcohol use

Instagram || Goodreads || The StoryGraph