Book Review: Have Yourself a Married Little Christmas by Claire Cain

Rating: ★★★☆
Audience: Contemporary Holiday Romance
Length: 284 pages
Author: Claire Cain
Publisher: Self Published
Release Date: November 20th, 2024
Image & Other Reviews on: Goodreads

BOOK SUMMARY:

My cheery little life was chugging along smoothly until one small shift sent it off track until it imploded. I lost my health, my business plans, and even my apartment—Merry Christmas to me! It’s at this low point Colonel Gruff, a man I know dislikes me, finds me.

He’s the grumpy soldier with a personality like sandpaper, but suddenly he’s offering me a solution to my problems I can’t say no to, and in a matter of weeks, I’m Mrs. Colonel Gruff.

I’m giving him what he needs too—a wife for the holidays. We’ll play pretend for his family, and even though he hasn’t said why, I know convincing them is important. And though this is all part of the agreement, those sugar plum fairies dancing around in my chest every time he gets close aren’t part of the deal.

I’m not ready to give up mistletoe kisses with my fake husband, or this glimpse of his secret soft side. But we’re only married for the holidays. I can’t keep him—even if he’s all I want for Christmas.

Have Yourself a Married Little Christmas is a closed door romance without implied intimacy.

MISSING SOME CHEMISTRY.

I thought this was a sweet marriage of convenience romance (and I love a MOC trope). But I did struggle with the chemistry between the main couple. I wanted to feel more passion by the time those closing chapters were coming around and I don’t think it ever hit that level.

The holiday aspects were good and I adore forced proximity so there were many enjoyable moments throughout. I liked the characters well enough too and did think they got along well. I was tired of hearing Gruff talk about his ex-wife though (I understand a few mentions, but this seemed constant).

So I don’t know, kind of a mixed bag for me on this read. I’m glad it was a quick story at least and I still like CC’s books. This one just missed a few marks for me.

Overall audience notes:

  • Christmas Romance
  • Language: none
  • Romance: closed door

Instagram || Goodreads || The StoryGraph

Book Review: The Holiday Club by Ashley Manley

Rating: ★★★★★
Audience: Holiday Romance Novella
Length: 203 pages
Author: Ashley Manley
Publisher: Self Published
Release Date: October 30th, 2025
Image & Other Reviews on: Goodreads

BOOK SUMMARY:

She’s lost the holidays she loved. He never wanted them in the first place. But this Christmas, everything could change.

Hollis Hartwell lives for parades on Main Street, matching pajamas, and small-town holiday magic—until a custody agreement hands every Christmas and town festival to her ex-husband. Now, with her magazine column on festive traditions looming and her heart anything but merry, Hollis is desperate for a new way to celebrate.

Enter Jay Randall. A rugged nonconformist who’d rather spend December riding a horse and buggy with his oddball best friend than decking any halls. When Hollis barges into their anti-Christmas plans hoping to prove that traditions matter, she gets more than she bargained for.

Sparks fly, beliefs are challenged, and amid beertending and unexpected pear trees, Hollis begins to wonder if the best traditions are the ones you create for yourself.

(please note, this title contains explicit language and romance)

OOOH I LOVED THIS.

Who knew that this charming novella would find its way to me this season and totally light up my day? I mean, it does kind of gut punch you in the beginning, but stay the course!!

I think as a parent, the sentiments surrounding creating the “perfect” holiday season and trying to accomplish all the things is what sang to me most. Understanding and realizing what’s actually important and what your children are truly noticing.

And I liked the romance!! For a novella I thought the slow burn was honestly pretty good. It gets a touch spicy for me, but easy to skip over. I loved the unconventional gang between Jay, Marv and Hollis. The core themes of this book just really spoke to me and I devoured this one.

Overall audience notes:

  • Holiday Romance Novella
  • Language: moderate
  • Romance: 2-3ish open door
  • Violence: low
  • Content warnings: cheating (recounted), divorice

Instagram || Goodreads || The StoryGraph

Book Review: 12 Days of Mistletoe by Jen Atkinson

Rating: ★★★★
Audience: Contemporary Holiday Romance
Length: 328 pages
Author: Jen Atkinson
Publisher: Self Published
Release Date: November 14th, 2024
Image & Other Reviews on: Goodreads

BOOK SUMMARY:

How to end up in Christmas kissing lessons with your downstairs enemy…

Break apartment rules? Guilty.
Send holiday cards to the downstairs neighbor’s grandma? Done.
Accidentally become said neighbor’s fake girlfriend for a family Christmas photo? Wait, what?

I, Bonnie Miller, am no troublemaker. I’m just an anxious girl trying to keep my emotional support pup in a no-pets apartment building. But my downstairs neighbor is determined to be my personal Grinch and get us both evicted.

Just when I think things can’t get any worse, Elliot Eaton offers me a deal I can’t refuse. Suddenly I’m playing girlfriend and giving mistletoe kisses to my sworn enemy, all to keep my home.

Who knew that breaking one little rule would lead to a fan-mistletoe-tastic holiday?

12 Days of Mistletoe is a closed door, laugh out loud, warm your wintery heart romcom. If you need a book with all the feels, some mistletoe kisses, and lots of holiday spirit, look no further!

LOVED THE ANXIETY REP.

This was my first book by this author and I think I would read another one! I was spouting genuine laughter during those opening scenes and chapters. I loved the fake dating plot and the wildness of Elliot’s family. It’s light and holiday themed with a nice whimsical feel to it.

I don’t always love a meddling grandmother so that one bugged me here and there. Let people kiss on their own terms, ya know?? But I did enjoy the family dynamics on a larger scale.

The anxiety representation was heartfelt too. I connected to many thoughts and feelings from Bonnie and appreciated those dynamics woven into the story too. Not mad at all that I added this to my holiday reads this year.

Overall audience notes:

  • Contemporary Holiday Romance
  • Language: none
  • Romance: kisses
  • Content Warnings: anxiety attacks (on page)

Instagram || Goodreads || The StoryGraph

Book Review: Silent Heist by Jenessa Fayeth

Rating: ★★★★
Audience: Holiday Romance
Length: 225 pages
Author: Jenessa Fayeth
Publisher: Self Published
Release Date: November 19th, 2025
Image & Other Reviews on: Goodreads

BOOK SUMMARY:

He came for the painting…

Soren Stapley is a professional thief. He is prepared for every scenario and has a plan for every situation.

But he never planned for her.

The painting he needs? It’s being guarded by the woman he once loved and the nine-year-old terror she’s nannying.

What’s worse? He’s not the only one hunting it down.

Christmas is about to get complicated…

…she became his reason to stay.

Maya Perry is out of options. Her job as a nanny is the only thing standing between her and rock bottom, and she’s not about to lose it—not to Arabella Hartwell, a feral child with a Nerf gun she nannies, and definitely not to the thief who shattered her heart. Soren may be charming, but he’s dangerous. And still the guy who broke her heart and apparently learned absolutely nothing about knocking.
It’s only a matter of time before he disappears again, but this time, Maya isn’t going to break.
At least, that’s the plan.

Silent Heist is an adventure filled, closed door, Christmas romantic comedy inspired by Home alone.

I’D REC IT.

Y’all know I go on a big holiday romance quest every year and this one came highly recommended. I really do love reading a Christmas romance that brings a different vibe than the usual and the light heist vibes of this one were fun!

I think what works great for shorter stories like this is that there’s some kind of second chance angle. And this one pulled at my heart strings!! I loved the little mentions and notions to their back story and you could see the chemistry between Maya and Soren from the beginning.

I’m not sure all of the Home Alone antics worked for me? But I know that’s totally a personal preference. For a book set entirely in one location I was impressed at the plot created. I definitely plan to continue reading Jenessa Fayeth’s books.

Overall audience notes:

  • Holiday Romance
  • Language: none
  • Romance: kisses
  • Violence: mild

Instagram || Goodreads || The StoryGraph