
Rating: ★★★
Audience: Contemporary Holiday Romance
Length: 361 pages
Author: Kristen Bailey
Publisher: Storm Publishing
Release Date: October 21st, 2025
Image & Other Reviews on: Goodreads
BOOK SUMMARY:
One woman, two Nicks, and a Christmas season that’s about to get very complicated.
When librarian Kay bumps into her ex-boyfriend Nick at a Christmas market, she thinks fate is finally giving her a second chance with her first big love. But then she gets spectacularly tangled in a Christmas tree-netting machine and meets another Nick entirely. One who cuts her free, dresses her wounds, and makes her pulse race in ways that thoroughly confuse her.
Finance Nick is successful, settled, and ready to talk five-year plans. Farmer Nick makes handcrafted furniture, supports local charities, and sees the creative spirit Kay has kept hidden behind her library desk. But how is a girl to choose?
Soon she’s spending her days delivering books to children’s hospitals and care homes with farmer Nick, before dashing home to whip off her reindeer onesie and glam up for romantic dates at the ballet with finance Nick.
But the countdown to Christmas is on, and Kay can’t keep this up forever. Somehow she must navigate London’s most complicated love triangle, avoid getting any more pine needles stuck in her hair – and work out once and for all which Nick has her heart.
A laugh-out-loud festive rom-com that fans of Love Actually and The Holiday will adore.

NOT IT.
I’ve enjoyed Kristen Bailey’s previous holiday romances but this one bugged me too much to love it.
My biggest gripe was that the FMC, Kay, was incredibly frustrating. She calls herself a “special kind of idiot” when she finally clues in [at 95%] and I was like YEAH YOU HAVE BEEN GIRL. WHY WERE YOU WITH THE WRONG MAN FOR 95% OF THIS BOOK.
If the break up had come much sooner I might have gotten more on board. It just left the other side of this love triangle lacking in a lot of ways because she wasn’t technically single even though she tried to maintain that thought process throughout the book. It became increasingly frustrating.
There’s good holiday cheer and themes that I did like. But as a romance, it didn’t work.
Overall audience notes:
- Contemporary holiday romance
- Language: mild
- Romance: closed door
- Violence: low

Instagram || Goodreads || The StoryGraph



