Book Review: Better Luck Next Time by Cara Bastone

Rating: ★★
Audience: Contemporary Romance + Magical Realism
Length: 4.5 hour audiobook
Author: Cara Bastone
Publisher: Audible Originals
Release Date: May 15th, 2025
Image & Other Reviews on: Goodreads

BOOK SUMMARY:

Two frenemies find a surprising second chance in this timeslip rom-com, starring Mae Whitman ( Parenthood ), Colin Woodell ( The Flight Attendant ), and a full cast.

Mona and Duncan used to be best friends. Now they can’t stand each other. Too bad that’s not a good enough excuse to miss their two families’ annual trip to the cabin. But things get really complicated when they accidentally drive through a wormhole together on the way. Look what playing nice and carpooling gets you.

Now they’re stranded indoors by an epic storm and stuck in an alternate timeline where things are just slightly … off. Duncan and his dad aren’t speaking for reasons no one knows, Mona’s mom doesn’t like her hair or her career choices, and their siblings are meddlesome as ever.

Oh, yeah, and apparently they’re going through a divorce. Which means that in this universe they are married. To each other.

All they can really do is play along until they figure out how to get back to the real timeline. How hard can it be—they already hate each other, don’t they? But figuring out how exactly Mona and Duncan managed to fall epically in love with one another—and then break each other’s hearts—is easier said than done. Navigating all these big feelings is leading to new ones, but are they destined to hurt each other in any universe? And what happens to this new relationship when they’re back to their old lives?

YEAH, NO.

This was one of those short romances where I am convinced that there is no way the couple made it past the epilogue. You can not make me think otherwise.

The magical realism/sci-fi-ish element didn’t bug me. It’s a quirk to the story that was fine. I thought that helped both of the leads have some growth and acknowledgement of feelings. There were some banter moments that were cute.

But, the love scenes were super cringey and I honestly thought that Mona and Duncan hated each other. And not in the cute enemies to lovers way. Unfortunately not my favorite Bastone book.

Overall audience notes:

  • Contemporary Romance / Magical realism
  • Language: low
  • Romance: vague open door
  • Violence: low

Instagram || Goodreads || The StoryGraph

Book Review: Maybe This Time by Cara Bastone

Rating: ★★★★
Audience: Contemporary Romance
Length: 5h 45 min audiobook
Author: Cara Bastone
Publisher: Audible Originals
Release Date: May 2nd, 2024
Image & Other Reviews on: Goodreads

BOOK SUMMARY:

Finding true love is only a matter of time in this heartfelt and hilarious romantic comedy, starring Zoë Chao (The Afterparty), Noah Reid (Schitt’s Creek), and a full cast!

Romance can be a little complicated when you get sucked into a wormhole. Just ask high school English teacher June Flint. One little solar flare happens and suddenly you find yourself 85 years in the future. Eighty-five years from your dream job. Your ailing mother whose only companion in this world is you. Your favorite stuffed-crust pizza from DeLucia’s on Sunday nights.

But when June’s cell phone inexplicably picks up a signal, she’s able to call back to the present—more specifically, four weeks before she accidentally time traveled. Problem is, the phone can only call one number: her work nemesis, gym teacher Mikey Shannon.

Now future June must help Mikey befriend present-day June to keep her from disappearing. But present-day June doesn’t even want to be in the same room as Mikey, let alone become besties. And Mikey isn’t exactly…talkie. Yet he’s spending hours a day with future June on the phone, and even more time trying to befriend present-day June. Volunteering with June at school, check. Facing his fear of roller coasters to make June smile, check. Adopting a puppy and letting her name it. Check.

But what does succeeding in the present mean for future June, and for the serious feelings she and Mikey are starting to catch for one another? Stopping time travel is one thing—but can they stop themselves from falling in love?

FUN AND QUIRKY.

I’ve come to really enjoy Cara Bastone’s audiobooks. They are fun and light and bring a smile to my face. I thought the concept of this one was unique and brought in a bunch of quirks that worked for the story being told.

I liked the dynamic between Mikey and June. Their phone calls were sweet and I loved the way they go to know each other on different levels and at different times. Things came together exactly as they should and this is a quick read if you’re needing something new to listen to.

Overall audience notes:

  • Contemporary Romance
  • Language: low
  • Romance: kisses

Instagram || Goodreads || The StoryGraph

Book Review: Love at First Psych by Cara Bastone

Rating: ★★★★
Audience: Contemporary Romance
Length: 4h 35 min audiobook
Author: Cara Bastone
Publisher: Audible Audio
Release Date: March 2nd, 2023
Image & Other Reviews on: Goodreads

BOOK SUMMARY:

True love is put to the test in this romantic comedy brought to hilarious life by Santino Fontana (Frozen, The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel), Stephanie Einstein, and a full cast!

This Psych 312 assignment just might send me off the deep end. Determining whether love at first sight really exists with Robbie Moravian as my project partner of all people?

He’s the sappiest man alive, so upbeat I could scream, and clearly rooting for happy endings at every turn. How does he not learn from experience considering our own meet-cute last semester almost got us expelled?

But we both need to pass this course to graduate. So we’re interviewing five random couples about their meet-cutes and relationships and spending all this time together. Which is certainly…educational.

Because it turns out Robbie isn’t just the charming golden boy I thought I knew. There’s some actual depth beneath all those lame dad jokes and the ‘70s-inspired thrift wardrobe (even if he does look ridiculously great in a flared collar). Next thing I know he’s walking me back to my office on the regular and finishing all my sentences and protecting me from freak storms, and…

Wait. Could Robbie be right? Can happy endings really come from unhappy beginnings? Is he about to change my entire world view?

Group projects are the worst.

SUPER CUTE.

I hope these short and sweet audiobooks by Bastone never stop because I have really adored each one. This was another great, quick read that brought a smile to my face.

I loved Robbie’s BIG golden retriever energy and the reverse grump x sunshine dynamic. I know Marigold comes off a bit poorly in the beginning, but with this being so short you see the growth in her character quickly. Yes, it’s all a bit cheesy and can feel a bit much. I liked it for what it was and the boost of serotonin it gave me.

All of the interviews left pulled me out of the story and I wish those would have been shortened or not overall included. I know it was the basis of the plot, yet I was easily side tracked and wanting more of the romance between the main couple.

Cute and quick, recommend if you’re needing something light and simple.

Overall audience notes:

  • Contemporary Romance Novella
  • Language: none
  • Romance: kisses

Instagram || Goodreads || The StoryGraph

Book Review: Just a Heartbeat Away (Forever Yours #1) by Cara Bastone

Rating: ★★★
Audience: Contemporary Romance
Length: 384 pages
Author: Cara Bastone
Publisher: HQN Books
Release Date: June 30th, 2020
Image & Other Reviews on: Goodreads

BOOK SUMMARY:

Some people change your life

Others change your heart

Newly widowed dad Sebastian Dorner was unraveling at the edges—until his son’s teacher, Via DeRosa, threw him a lifeline. Now, two years later, they reconnect at Matty’s new school, and an inconvenient but unmistakable jolt of attraction crackles between them. But why does the first person to spark with Sebastian in years have to be a millennial? Is twentysomething Via really too young for him or does fortysomething Sebastian just feel too damn old?

A former foster kid, Via’s finally forged the stable life she’s always dreamed of—new job, steady income, no drama. The last thing she needs are rumors about her and a single dad at school. But why does she keep being drawn into his capable, worn-flannel orbit? And why does being around Sebastian, Matty and even their dog, Crabby, seem to spark so much want?

They’re trying to ignore the tension threatening their friendship. But sometimes what’ll heal you is just a touch—and a heartbeat—away.

DID NOT START OFF WELL.

Okay.

This book made me realize one of my biggest contemporary romance pet peeves.

I HATE when one of the love interests starts off in a relationship. Just super unnecessary for me. It makes all of those good moments between them when that chemistry is starting to build feel tainted by the fact that someone is still attached to someone else. UGH. And in this book it wasn’t until 60%+ where it was confirmed Via was at last single.

Since that brought my rating real low I’ll throw in a few things I did like. I liked the other tropes and conversations surrounding grief, resilience and moving on. There’s some good moments about being in a relationship with a larger age gap and what that can mean for both parties. Solid side characters who were supportive friends to Sebastian and Via.

Also this was oddly Hallmarky and then got dashed with way more heated spice RIGHT at the very end that I was a bit taken back. Easy to skim over since it’s at the end, but if you’re waiting for that slow burn to kick in, it eventually does.

Overall audience notes:

  • Contemporary Romance
  • Language: some strong
  • Romance: multiple open door concentrated at the end
  • Trigger/Content Warnings: widower, mentions of growing up in foster homes, depictions of grief

Instagram || Goodreads || The StoryGraph